Shopify’s Extra Fee for Razorpay and Cashfree: The Real Per-Order Maths

Shopify charges an extra transaction fee when you take payment through Razorpay, Cashfree or any gateway other than Shopify Payments. It is a percentage of the order, it sits on top of what the gateway charges, and it falls as you move up Shopify’s plans. On a low-margin catalogue it is worth doing the arithmetic.
The fee nobody mentions at signup
There are two separate charges on every order. The gateway takes its cut for moving the money. Shopify takes a smaller percentage for the fact that you used someone else. Most store owners only find the second one when they reconcile a month of payouts.
The exact percentages change by plan and over time, so read them from your own Shopify billing page rather than from any article, this one included. What does not change is the shape of the problem, which is what the rest of this covers.
Working out what it costs you
Take your average order value, multiply by Shopify’s third-party fee percentage for your plan, and multiply by your monthly order count. That is the annualised cost of not using Shopify Payments.
Then compare it against the difference between your current plan and the next one up. If the fee saving exceeds the plan increase, upgrading pays for itself, and it is one of the few cases where a software company upselling you is also the cheaper option.
Why Indian stores use another gateway anyway
Shopify Payments is not available everywhere, and Indian stores have reasons to prefer a local gateway regardless: UPI handling, local support in your timezone, settlement cycles that suit your cash flow, and cash on delivery behaviour. Those can be worth more than the fee.
If COD is part of the reason, make sure it is set up on Shopify’s side rather than the gateway’s, or you pay for a gateway on orders where no money moves online. We wrote that up in stopping Razorpay asking COD customers to pay upfront.
What else to count before switching
- Settlement time, because cash in three days is worth more than cash in seven
- Refund handling, which can differ sharply between gateways
- Whether your accountant can reconcile the payout file easily
- What happens to subscriptions or saved cards if you move
The honest summary
For a store doing a handful of orders a day, this fee is a rounding error and not worth a weekend. For a store doing hundreds, it is a real line in the accounts and deserves a spreadsheet. Work out which you are before anyone sells you a migration.
If the wider platform question is open rather than just the gateway one, Shopify against WooCommerce for an Indian business takes it from the top.
Fees, COD and refunds are all the same conversation about how money moves through your store. We handle them together as part of Shopify development, and the refund trap is in why Razorpay refunds do not show in Shopify orders.
Does the fee apply to cash on delivery orders?
It applies to payments processed through a third-party gateway. A true Shopify manual COD order is not processed by a gateway, which is another reason to set COD up on Shopify’s side.
Is Shopify Payments available in India?
Availability changes by country and over time. Check your own admin, because the answer there is the only one that counts for your store.
Can I negotiate the fee?
Not on standard plans. It is part of the published pricing and moves only when your plan does.
Does moving to WooCommerce avoid it?
Yes, WooCommerce charges no platform fee on transactions. You take on hosting, maintenance and security instead, which are real costs of their own.
Want the sums done on your store?
Send your average order value, monthly orders and current plan. We will tell you whether changing anything is worth it.